A series of articles emphasizing practical
knowledge you can't find in practice guides
and interviews with experts who share
their techniques for effective and efficient
case management

Archives

This issue, Marjory Harris reviews some really bad movies.

The Case of the Disappearing Video, or “Injured Worker Working, The Movie” I waited patiently for defense counsel to appear at a deposition with the Agreed Medical Evaluator. The adjuster had told me the purpose of the deposition was to show surveillance videos to the AME. When defense counsel arrived, I asked where the equipment was. “What equipment?” he asked. “Aren’t you showing videos?” I asked. “No, I just had a few questions of the doctor about his report.” He then went on to ask some questions that could have been addressed in a supplemental report. Later he as much as admitted that when the insurance company’s legal department saw the video, on the day of the deposition, they realized they had to bury it.		Entrapment Does the video prove the private investigator violated the law? The investigator is an agent of defendant. Injured Worker’s Declaration
It was the oddest video I had ever been sent. It began with a man sitting on his desk in an office with tacky wood paneling. He was wearing a beret and sunglasses and facing the camera. “This is [Name Changed], private investigator operating out of Fresno, California, license number [007].” He states that the videotaping will begin at around 10:00 a.m. and "will run until done. All times and dates on the videotape are accurate." In the next scene, we are on the streets of San Francisco, on a steep hill with the Bay glittering in the sunlight. The man in the black beret and sunglasses is now standing by his truck, talking with Injured Worker. Next we see Injured Worker gingerly wiping the truck with his good arm. The bad arm is in a sling. Note that Injured Worker has never denied that he is trying to establish a small business detailing vehicles. He is not receiving either temporary disability or state disability. He had told his doctor and the AME that because of his bad arm, it takes him so long to detail a vehicle that he cannot make a living doing this, as he had planned to before the industrial injury. After some minutes showing Injured Worker slowly polishing the side of the investigator's truck, the film abruptly ends. < Previous | Next >